Taxing Lessons From Court Decisions

Decisions — Separation Issues

Thanks for sharing!
Image source: Free Picture: A Pair Of Padlocks ID: 121547 Ragne Kabanova Dreamstime Stock Photos
Image source: Free Picture: A Pair Of Padlocks ID: 121547 Ragne Kabanova Dreamstime Stock Photos

When you’re married and file a separate federal income tax return, section 6013 of the internal revenue code says you can change to a joint return later (within certain limitations).

One of the limitations to “filing a joint return after filing a separate return” is that you can’t switch if you received a notice of deficiency and filed a petition with the tax court.

That seems clear.

But what if you mistakenly file your return as head of household and later want to change to married filing joint? Does the initial return qualify as a “separate” return? Or does “separate return” as used in the code section mean only a return that was originally filed as married filing separately?

The tax code contains no definition of “separate return.” But the meaning was important in T.C. Memo. 2014-8 (Ibrahim) because the taxpayer would lose his claim to a substantial earned income credit if he couldn’t change his filing status.

In this case, the taxpayer, a Somalian immigrant, was married and lived with his wife and eight children. Based on the advice of a tax service, he claimed the head of household filing status on his 2011 federal income tax return.

The IRS said, correctly, that the taxpayer was not eligible for the head of household filing status. Instead, since he was married and did not file a joint return with his wife, the taxpayer’s correct filing status was married filing separately. In addition, the taxpayer could not now choose to change to married filing joint because he had already received the notice of deficiency and filed the tax court case.

The taxpayer argued he had not filed a “separate” return. He says the term “separate return” as used in the code section refers only to returns filed using the married filing separately status.

The court agreed with the IRS. “Although [the] case produces an unfortunate result, we cannot depart from the clear bar of section 6013(b)(2)(B) and must apply the law as it is written. Thus, [the taxpayer] is ineligible to elect to amend his return to file jointly with his spouse.”

The taxpayer appealed.

The appeals court looked at the same issue. Does a “separate return” as used in internal revenue code section 6013(b)(1) include a head-of-household return?

If the taxpayer’s head-of-household return was a “separate return” under section 6013(b)(1), he could not make a joint return because he received and challenged the notice of deficiency.

However, if his head-of-household return was not a separate return, the limitations of section 6013(b)(2)(B) did not apply.

Here’s the relevant part of code section 6013:

(b) Joint return after filing separate return

(1) In general

Except as provided in paragraph (2), if an individual has filed a separate return for a taxable year for which a joint return could have been made by him and his spouse under subsection (a) and the time prescribed by law for filing the return for such taxable year has expired, such individual and his spouse may nevertheless make a joint return for such taxable year. A joint return filed by the husband and wife under this subsection shall constitute the return of the husband and wife for such taxable year, and all payments, credits, refunds, or other repayments made or allowed with respect to the separate return of either spouse for such taxable year shall be taken into account in determining the extent to which the tax based upon the joint return has been paid. If a joint return is made under this subsection, any election (other than the election to file a separate return) made by either spouse in his separate return for such taxable year with respect to the treatment of any income, deduction, or credit of such spouse shall not be changed in the making of the joint return where such election would have been irrevocable if the joint return had not been made. If a joint return is made under this subsection after the death of either spouse, such return with respect to the decedent can be made only by his executor or administrator.

(2) Limitations for making of election

The election provided for in paragraph (1) may not be made—

(A) after the expiration of 3 years from the last date prescribed by law for filing the return for such taxable year (determined without regard to any extension of time granted to either spouse); or

(B) after there has been mailed to either spouse, with respect to such taxable year, a notice of deficiency under section 6212, if the spouse, as to such notice, files a petition with the Tax Court within the time prescribed in section 6213; or

(C) after either spouse has commenced a suit in any court for the recovery of any part of the tax for such taxable year; or

(D) after either spouse has entered into a closing agreement under section 7121 with respect to such taxable year, or after any civil or criminal case arising against either spouse with respect to such taxable year has been compromised under section 7122.

 

HOW WOULD YOU DECIDE THE APPEAL?

Make your selection, then see “The Court’s Decision” below for a full explanation

For the

or

for the

THE COURT’S DECISION

For a full explanation, hover your mouse over the link

View the full case in the window below, or download a complete copy of the PDF by clicking the “Download” link.

Note: Taxing Lessons provides a summarized version of sometimes lengthy court decisions. The full case may include facts and issues not presented here. Please use the link provided to read the entire case.

Download (PDF, 145KB)

***

This information should not be considered legal, investment or tax advice. Taxing Lessons and Top Drawer Ink Corp. do not provide legal, investment or tax advice. Always consult your legal, investment and/or tax advisor regarding your personal situation.

***

Other posts you might enjoy

Decisions — Going, going, partially gone Image source: Public domain, ©creativecommonsstockphotos ID 83023111 Dreamstime Stock Photos   Morning found us calmly unaware…and then the roof came off and we learned we forgot to file an election with our tax return. That's not exactly how the lyrics of the old rock song go. Howeve...
Decisions — Home A-Gain Image source: openclipart.org   Like the movie franchise, home is where our story begins. But in this case (Forde, Docket No. 1280-16), the thieves owned the home. The taxpayer and his wife purchased the home in 1998 for $835,000. Over the next few years, through 2001, the taxpayer de...
Decisions — Smoking the deductions Image source: ©Melinda Nagy Dreamstime Stock Photos   We're not lost. We just don't know where we are. Words that create a phantom distinction where no difference exists can make us laugh. Except of course when they involve tax law. In T.C. Memo. 2017-211 (Feinberg), the taxpayer w...
Decisions — Point of Interest Image source: wpclipart.com   What's the point? In 149 T.C. No. 17 (CreditGuard of America, Inc.), the court answers the question of at what point a corporation has to start paying interest on a tax liability. The taxpayer, a credit counseling organization, was incorporated in Flor...
Right answer!
Sorry, wrong answer :(
For the Taxpayer.

The code’s plain language is that “separate return” refers only to married filing separately. See sections 1(d), 6654(d)(1)(C)(ii), 7703(b).

Since the taxpayer did not file a separate return within the meaning of section 6013(b)(1), section 6013(b)(2)(B) does not prohibit him from amending his status to married filing jointly.

Thus, the taxpayer is entitled to the resulting credit and refund.

Tagged , , ,