Taxing Lessons From Court Decisions

Form vs. Substance – Deductible Expenses

Thanks for sharing!
1 minute read

Form vs substance

When you pay tax-deductible expenses for someone who’s not your dependent, who gets the deduction?

In T.C. Memo. 2010-286 (Lang), the question arose when a mother paid medical bills and real estate tax for her daughter, and the daughter deducted those expenses on her personal income tax return.

The IRS said mom wasn’t responsible for the expenses, and therefore couldn’t deduct them, and that the daughter, who was responsible for them, hadn’t paid them and therefore couldn’t deduct them.

The daughter argued that she was entitled to the deductions, saying the transaction was no different than if her mother had given her the money as a gift and she had paid the expenses herself.

At issue: $24,559 of medical expenses and $5,508 of real estate taxes.

The court, noting there was no issue of a double deduction since the mother had not claimed the expenses on her return, agreed with the daughter and allowed the deductions.

***

Other posts you might enjoy

Decisions — To be fair   Image source: Library of Congress Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons   All may be fair in love and war, but that's not necessarily true in taxes. In TC Memo 2018-117 (Grainger), the taxpayer made noncash charitable donations and claimed a deduction for what she believed wa...
Decisions — Who’s included?   Image source: openclipart.org   Back in 2012, the tax court decided a case typically referred to as WHO515. In that case, the question was whether certain partnership tax items were included when a taxpayer agreed to an extension of the statute of limitations for a personal fed...
Decisions — Sharing the credit Image source: Photo by Sharas Kveder on Unsplash   You may be amazed by what you can accomplish if you don't care who gets the credit, but that's probably not the best argument to make in tax court. In T.C. Memo. 2018-81 (Caselli), the taxpayer was one of three shareholders in a subch...
Decisions — If not A, than C Image source: wpclipart.com   No, the title doesn't refer to an obscure math problem that you'll need to solve. The question to be solved in T.C. Memo. 2018-75 (Fiedziuszko) is whether the taxpayer is a statutory employee who can deduct expenses on Schedule C, Profit or Loss from Busines...
Tagged ,