Taxing Lessons From Court Decisions

Reasonable Cause

Thanks for sharing!
2 minute read

Pointing Finger

Image source: openclipart.org

When you accidentally run afoul of tax rules, you may be able to avoid the resulting penalties if you have reasonable cause for your error.

One typical example of reasonable cause is reliance on a tax advisor. The tax court has found that it’s reasonable to rely on a competent advisor regarding a matter of tax law, such as whether a liability exists, or whether return is due.

This excuse does have limits. For example, relying on your advisor to file your tax return in a timely manner is not reasonable cause for avoiding penalties on late filing. The question the court asks is whether you relied on your advisor that no return was due, or whether you relied on your advisor to file your return on time.

In Tesoriero (T.C. Memo. 2012-216), the taxpayer filed his 2004 federal income tax return on August 15, 2005. He believed his accountant had filed an extension of time, and that the return was therefore timely. The IRS had no record of receiving the extension, and assessed penalties for late filing.

Because there was no doubt the taxpayer was required to file the return, and his advisor did not tell him he was not required to file, the court said the taxpayer did not have reasonable cause to avoid the penalty.

That was true even though the accountant testified that he had mailed the forms, and the court did not doubt his veracity. However, the accountant did not mail the extension using registered or certified mail, or an authorized private delivery service, so he had no proof it was sent to the IRS.

Since this case is appealable to the Second Circuit, and that court holds that no other proof, including testimony, demonstrates actual receipt by the IRS (see code section 7502), the taxpayer was unable to establish that he filed a valid extension request.

Taxing Lesson: In taxes, as in life, you are responsible for your actions – even if it’s not your fault you never learned to accept responsibility.

***

Other posts you might enjoy

Decisions — To be fair   Image source: Library of Congress Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons   All may be fair in love and war, but that's not necessarily true in taxes. In TC Memo 2018-117 (Grainger), the taxpayer made noncash charitable donations and claimed a deduction for what she believed wa...
Decisions — Who’s included?   Image source: openclipart.org   Back in 2012, the tax court decided a case typically referred to as WHO515. In that case, the question was whether certain partnership tax items were included when a taxpayer agreed to an extension of the statute of limitations for a personal fed...
Decisions — Completely gifted Image source: Jon Tyson on Unsplash   "No" is a complete sentence, and "no" is what the taxpayer in letter ruling 201825003 hopes the IRS will say. The taxpayer owns a collection of artwork. She and her now-deceased spouse entered into a deed of transfer with two museums. Under the de...
Decisions — Sharing the credit Image source: Photo by Sharas Kveder on Unsplash   You may be amazed by what you can accomplish if you don't care who gets the credit, but that's probably not the best argument to make in tax court. In T.C. Memo. 2018-81 (Caselli), the taxpayer was one of three shareholders in a subch...
Tagged , ,